Googles Good-Writing Filter

I was recently struck by the fact that the top-ranking web pages on Google are consistently much better written than the vast majority of what one reads on the web. Yet traditional SEO wisdom has little to say about good writing. Does Google, the world's wealthiest media company, really rank web pages based primarily on arcane technical criteria such as keyword density, link text, or even PageRank?

Apparently not.

Most Common Website Content Success Factors

I took a close look at the top five pages for the five most searched-on keywords, as identified by WordTracker on June 27, 2005. Here's what I found.

The web pages that contained written content (a small but significant portion were image galleries) all shared the following features:

  • Updating: frequent updating of content, at least once every few weeks, and more often, once a week or more.
  • Spelling and grammar: few or no errors. No page had more than three misspelled words or four grammatical errors. Note: spelling and grammar errors were identified by using Microsoft Word's check feature, and then ruling out words marked as misspellings that are either proper names or new words that are simply not in the dictionary. Google almost certainly has better access to new words than the dictionary, with its database of billions of web pages. Supposed grammatical errors that did not in fact violate style rules were also ignored. Google would certainly be less conservative than a grammar checker in evaluating popular stylistic devices such as sentence fragments.
  • Paragraphs: primarily brief (1-4 sentences). Few or no long blocks of text.
  • Lists: both bulleted and numbered, form a large part of the text.
  • Sentence length: mostly brief (10 words or fewer). Medium-length and long sentences are sprinkled throughout the text rather than clumped together.
  • Contextual relevance: text contains numerous terms related to the keyword, as well as stem variations of the keyword. The page may contain the keyword itself few times or not at all.

SEO "Do's" and "Don'ts" that Don't Really Matter

A hard look at the results slaughters a number of SEO bugbears and sacred cows.

  • PageRank. The median PageRank was 4. One page had a PageRank of 0. (Note that the low PageRank would seem to discount the idea that these pages owe their ranking completely to numerous incoming links.)
  • Frames. The top two web pages listed for the most searched-on keyword employ frames.
  • JavaScript-formatted internal links. Most of the websites use JavaScript for their internal page links.
  • Keyword optimization. Except for two pages, keyword optimization was conspicuous by its absence. In more than half the web pages, the keyword did not appear more than three times, meaning a very low density. Many of the pages did not contain the keyword at all.
  • Sub-headings. On most pages, sub-headings were either absent or in the form of images rather than text.
  • Links: Most of the web pages contained ten or more links; many contain over 30, in defiance of the SEO bugbears about "link popularity bleeding." Moreover, nearly all the pages contained a significant number of non-relevant links. On many pages, non-relevant links outnumbered relevant ones.
  • Text content: a significant number of pages contained little or no text. These pages were almost all image galleries (there was one Flash movie), with the images being photographs of the subject covered by the keyword.
  • Originality: a significant number of pages contained content copied from other websites. In all cases, the content was professionally written content apparently distributed on a free-reprint basis. Note: the reprint content did not consist of content feeds. However, no website consisted solely of free-reprint content. There was always at least a significant portion of original content, usually the majority of the page.

    • Recommendations

    • Make sure a professional writer, or at least someone who can tell good writing from bad, is creating your site's content, particularly in the case of a search-engine optimization campaign. If you are an SEO, make sure you get a pro to do the content. A shocking number of SEOs write incredibly badly. I've even had clients whose websites got fewer conversions or page views after their SEOs got through with them, even when they got a sharp uptick in unique visitors. Most visitors simply hit the "back" button when confronted with the unpalatable text, so the increased traffic is just wasted bandwidth.
    • If you write your own content, make sure that it passes through the hands of a skilled copyeditor or writer before going online.
    • Update your content often. It's important both to add new pages and update existing pages. If you can't afford original content, use free-reprint content.
    • Distribute your content to other websites on a free-reprint basis. This will help your website get links in exchange for the right to publish the content. It will also help spread your message and enhance your visibility. Fears of a "duplicate content penalty" for free-reprint content (as opposed to duplication of content within a single website) are unjustified.
    • In short, make sure the bulk of your investment in your website is devoted to its content, rather than graphic design, old-school search-engine optimization, or linking campaigns.

    Joel Walsh is the owner, founder and head-writer of UpMarket Content. To read more about website content best practices, get a consultation with Mr. Walsh, or get a sample page for your site at no charge, check out this web site content specialist information: http://www.upmarketcontent.com/web-site-cont ent/#seo.

    In The News:

    pen paper and inkwell


    cat break through


    Do Search Engines Like Your Web Site?

    Between 75% and 98.8% of visitors to Web sites come... Read More

    Search Engine Robots - How They Work, What They Do (Part II)

    If your site isn't found in the search engines, it... Read More

    Submitting to the Search Engines and WebCrawlers

    When you want your brand new site to be indexed... Read More

    An Easy Way Not to Get Banned by Google

    Strategic search engine optimization involves far more than keyword research,... Read More

    Search Engine Marketing: Are You Accidentally Hiding From Potential Customers?

    You may be hiding if the search engines can't 'see'... Read More

    Search Engine Optimization for Beginners

    If you are confused about terms like "search engine optimization"... Read More

    Five Short Quick Tips on Web Page Titles

    By Catherine FranzSearch engine spiders read and record page titles... Read More

    The Importance of Search Engine Optimization

    Search Engine Optimization is a key to any successful internet... Read More

    Playing By Googles Rules

    As the undisputable leader in search engines, Google places a... Read More

    A Link From An Ugly Duckling Website With A PR=1 Could Give You 10 to 80 Times More PageRank

    Whether you want to start a business and sell on... Read More

    All About Links -- Interview With Link Building Expert , Bob Gladstein

    Julia: Welcome Bob. Thank you for taking the time to... Read More

    Absolute Top Five Search Engine Marketing Myths Uncovered!

    It's no secret that Search Engine marketing can drive significant... Read More

    Optimizing Online Catalog Copy for the Search Engines

    It only makes sense. You have an e-commerce catalog site.... Read More

    The 7 Points of Do-It-Yourself SEO

    Ever felt intimidated at the convoluted, jargon-ridden information about Internet... Read More

    Introduction to Google Page Rank (PR)

    For anyone looking to enhance their Google Page Rank (PR)... Read More

    The Great Search Engine War, Where Content is King

    When search engines first appeared, they were simple affairs consisting... Read More

    Beyond Hits!

    Your Website visitor reports are a goldmine of information. If... Read More

    The Search Engine Of The Future: Mobility Has A Pricetag

    We all know the ease of using a search engine... Read More

    The Search Engine Optimization Game Is Getting Tricky

    For more than 4 years now I have been modifying... Read More

    How To Weather Google Algorithm Changes

    If you spend much time reading the various webmaster forums,... Read More

    Seecrets on Website Promotion: Search Engine Wars ? a Different Perspective

    The objective of all search engine providers is epitomized by... Read More

    7 Search Engine Optimization Mistakes and Solutions

    To many websites, webmasters discover that major sources of website... Read More

    The Myth of Guaranteed #1 Ranking in Search Engine Marketing

    You've seen the ads: Guaranteed #1 Ranking! There are no... Read More

    Determining the Value of Your SEO Service

    Every once in a while--and probably more often than we... Read More

    SEO Trade Secrets - 8 Great Tools for Search Engine Optimization

    About 80% of website traffic comes through search engines. And... Read More

    How Google Indexes Content From Your Web Directory

    In a fluke, I was able to notice something about... Read More

    Crash Course in Getting a #1 Google Ranking

    First, here's the rundown of some of the terminology I'm... Read More

    High Search Engine Rankings - A Long Term Strategy

    The last 1.5 years have shown major changes in search... Read More

    Why Top Search Engine Placements Never Move?

    #1 question when it comes to web advertising is how... Read More

    How To Design A Search Engine Friendly Website

    There are many websites that fail to target their required... Read More

    Keyword Optimization - How To Achieve It

    The most important thing you can do for your business... Read More

    Search Engine Optimization - Free Tips and Help - Part One - The Title Tag

    Search Engine Optimization is a widely misunderstood industry. Many webmasters,... Read More

    Google Contest - Nigritude Ultramarine

    Search engine optimization experts are having fun with Google. Experts,... Read More