Bad hiring decisions cost organizations, both in dollars and lost opportunities. But getting the right people in the right places doing the right thing is not easy. It requires painstaking efforts and objective information. Mergers, acquisitions, downsizing, and growth all require an unprecedented need for information about how to hire top performers and a framework for assessing the competencies required to lead people during extraordinary times. Therefore, hiring the right people involves more than guesswork and subjectivity. The formula is simple but not easy: know what a squirrel is and set a trap to catch them.
"Russian Doll" management, the phenomenon by which managers repeatedly hire and promote miniature versions of themselves, will not take organizations where they need to go. Instead, diversity of thought and creativity will be required to offer the ingenious solutions to tomorrow's complicated problems. Finding these superlative leaders of tomorrow requires hiring the best and brightest people now. However, many organizations continue to hire squirrels instead. What is a Squirrel?
Simply put, a squirrel is a creature that does not belong in your organization. It is a creature that, no matter how much you try, will for now and always be a squirrel. You can't fix squirrels. Trying to do so is a little like marrying a person and hoping you can change him or her. It just doesn't happen. Squirrels are uncooperative, aggressive, destructive creatures that will cost you company significant sums of money. In fact, some researchers estimate that a squirrely hire can cost your company up to four times that person's yearly salary. So, if you are hiring someone for a position that earns $100,000 a year, you are quickly facing the loss of a million dollars of damage if that person doesn't work out. Clearly, organizations want to avoid hiring squirrels, but how can you tell a squirrel from a non-squirrel? Set the Squirrel Trap
The first step in setting the squirrel trap is to put the person at ease. One of the things I do before an interview is the same thing that most interviewers do. I look at the resume. But in addition to looking for the usual things like experience and education, I search for something that we have in common. If the person has lived in a part of the world that I have, I make note of that; if we went to the same school, I remember that. I look for any shared experience that we might have. Whatever the hook, I use it to make the person feel more comfortable. Then, before starting the questions, I refer to the thing we have in common, often by making a joke about it.
Joking and using appropriate humor are ways to encourage others to lower their guard. For instance, I usually start by offering candidates something to drink: "Water? Do you want that on the rocks?" "Coffee? Leaded or unleaded?" "A coke? Want rum with that?" It's not hilarious stuff, but it does serve the purpose. It causes a smile or laugh, and the ice is broken.
The second phase of trap setting is to interview smarter. There are volumes of books written on the subject of good interviewing techniques, but here are a few that you may not have considered
· Ask why they left their last job. This is not revolutionary. Most seasoned interviewers make this a part of their protocol. The words of the candidate's answer are not as critical as the nonverbal responses, however. The candidate will have rehearsed a good reason for leaving: The position was eliminated; opportunities for growth were minimized; a merger caused redundancy in positions. All of these are valid reasons for leaving, but you have to be sure the answer is true. Instead of looking at your notes or reading from a resume, look at the person's eyes when you ask this one. Is the person looking you in the eye? Did the eyes dart left or right? Any facial touching? Fidgeting? Touching other objects? All can be an indication that the person is not telling the truth.
· Ask why they want to work in your organization. This one will show whether they have done their homework. If they are just looking for a job, that will show too.
· Give hypothetical scenarios and ask what they would do in each. No one can prepare for these kinds of questions, so you will get a glimpse of the thinking patterns of the individual. Most interviewers already do this one, but examining your scenarios and asking yourself whether they really get to the heart of what you're trying to discover can help you improve the value of the questions.
· Finally, ask about their areas for improvement. Everyone asks this one, so applicants anticipate it and prepare the malarkey responses. But you can push back and catch them off guard when they answer, "I expect too much from myself." By saying, "Oh come on. Every applicant since the Pharaoh hired pyramid workers has used that one. What's a real one? What would your direct reports tell me? What would your boss tell me?" If, after some serious probing on your part, the person still can't come up with any areas for improvement, the person is either unconscious or seriously dedicated to impression management.
Finally, gathering more and better data can help avoid hiring squirrels. Most interviewers rely on a pre-determined process to gather data. They request a resume, conduct an interview, check with references, and have subsequent meetings with other members of the organization. However, all this is still not always enough.
The use of psychometrics, assessments that have been validated for hiring, is one way to improve your hiring practices. A well-chosen battery of tests, one that includes both intellectual measures and personality assessments, can increase the validity of your conclusions. This combination measures applicants' current intellectual resources and forecasts the kinds of decision making and problem solving they are likely to engage in. I advocate using at least two cognitive measures, one timed and one un-timed, to determine whether deadlines and pressure will affect performance. Numerical testing should be included if the position requires budget or financial decision making.
I use at least five instruments that measure different aspects of work-related personality traits. Personality assessments offer crucial information because they indicate the candidate's achievement drive, ethics, and reliability-essentials for every job in every company. They also provide information about other kinds of personality characteristics that may help or hinder the person's ability to fit in and do the job. For example, people skills are essential for individuals applying for a sales position or a job in human resources. They are not so important for solo performers like accountants and engineers who will not have direct report responsibilities. Similarly, flexibility and adaptability are important traits for someone who works in a field that changes quickly and unexpectedly. They are not so critical for routine jobs that tend to stay the same most of the time.
All testing is not helpful, however. In fact, no testing is better than bad testing. Using only one assessment, using instruments that were never intended for making hiring decisions, and using tests that don't measure what you need not only waste time and money, this practice can put you at risk legally. Finally, having someone who had been trained in interpreting psychometrics is essential. The ability to aggregate the data from all the assessments is both a science and an art that requires years of experience to master. The money spent to hire a qualified person to interpret the data is minimal when compared to the cost of a bad new hire. Once you have all the salient data, you are ready to ask yourself the important question. Is this person a squirrel?
Ten Reasons Not to Hire Squirrels
· Not champions of innovation, squirrels are known as the "living fossils." They haven't changed in 5 million years. What are the chances they will be able to handle expected, much less unexpected change in your company? And respond to shifting priorities? Won't happen.
· Squirrels resolve conflict by foot stomping, tail flagging, chattering, and chasing. Not many people like conflict and even fewer are good at resolving it, but squirrely responses to conflict will get you sued.
· Aggressive and uncooperative, 32% of adult males have torn ears. Do this just one time in corporate America, and you have huge problems.
· Not good team players, squirrels are asocial and solitary. If the job requires any kind of collaboration, teamwork, or coordination of effort, a squirrel is not your rodent of choice.
· When confronted with a threat, squirrels stand motionless, swallow hard, and chew fast-so much for overcoming obstacles. Most companies require more of a "can do" spirit that squirrels just don't seem to be able to embody.
· The brains of squirrels are seldom engaged. The stomach rules. Some part of the brain has to work for success in most companies. The stomach should play a much lesser role.
· Because their sweat glands are in their paws, squirrels are lousy handshakers. Will this help build rapport with clients?
· There are 1600 different species of squirrels, but they are all seed-stealing thieves. Squirrels are sometimes tough to classify by the specific genus, but they all share the characteristic of being thieves. There's no place for an employee who will have a paw in the till.
· Squirrels spend most of they day sleeping and are usually only active around lunch time.
· Although cute and furry, squirrels are gnawing beasts that destroy property and make not attempts at restitution.
Bringing the wrong people into the organization compromises the leadership pipeline that each organization needs to fuel. Often, however, a crisis causes a company to make a poor hiring decision that costs them dearly. An alternative is to hire temporary help until a high potential candidate becomes available. Hiring smart is the first step to making sure the organization has the right people coming into the organization, but it is only the first step. Developing talented individuals for progression and succession is critical for the growth and success of the company over the long term.
Conclusion
Identifying an individual's strengths and approaches to work before making hiring decisions will help enhance reliability and build confidence that your company is hiring the most qualified candidate. Once this step is complete, the individual's boss can map out a plan and timeline for developing skills and gaining experience that will enable the person to move forward in the organization.
Smart companies, ones that want to select and retain talent in industries that are characterized by pirating, know that they must pioneer new ways to hire smart, develop talent, and teach the non-technical aspects of leading. Remember, a squirrel is just a rat in a cuter outfit.
Dr. Linda Henman speaks from experience. For more than 25 years, she has helped military organizations, small businesses, and Fortune 500 Companies turn things around by getting the right people in the right place doing the right thing.
Linda holds a Bachelor of Science in communication, two Master of Arts degrees in both interpersonal communication and organization development, and a Ph.D. in organizational systems. By combining her experience as an organizational psychologist with her education in business, she offers her clients assessment, coaching, consulting, and training solutions that are pragmatic in their approach and sound in their foundation. Specializing in assessment for selection, promotion, and development, Linda helps organizations improve their succession and retention initiatives.
To get the best results you have to be very... Read More
On communication: One of the biggest strains on the communication... Read More
In most industrialized nations, the average age a student graduates... Read More
Creativity can be defined as problem identification and idea generation... Read More
Bringing an HR consultant into your organisation can often be... Read More
An essential step in managing the performance of salespeople is... Read More
This article relates to the Work/Life Balance competency, which investigates... Read More
Key control, or more accurately the lack of key control... Read More
Teamwork is a process that can be experienced outdoors and... Read More
Being able to give effective feedback is not just a... Read More
Left alone it doesn't take long for a building with... Read More
Howard Dean's tenure as chairman of the Democratic National Committee... Read More
The current economy is causing most companies to tighten their... Read More
Globalisation, the expansion of intercontinental trade, technological advances and the... Read More
This module focuses on the basics of Knowledge Mapping, its... Read More
Ah, the wretched pain of delegation. It comes easy to... Read More
How should you keep track of meetings?Have you ever wanted... Read More
Recognizing good performance through praise or other positive action is... Read More
Today's successful organizations are the ones which carry on open... Read More
Imagine that you're a sports coach and you need a... Read More
Whether your company holds one meeting a week or dozens... Read More
Managers who aren't loyal to their people can't expect loyalty... Read More
You can't build a reputation on what you are "going"... Read More
Boisterous, Omnipotent, Self- indulgent Sociopath. Avoid the B.O.S.S. syndrome with... Read More
One of the strongest weapons available allows business, non-profit and... Read More
Meetings can be the life-blood of an organisation or the... Read More
There are so many ways to jump start your prifits... Read More
It's amazing what you can accomplish if you don't care... Read More
With deference to Dr. Covey and his very popular Seven... Read More
My friend Delia is the owner of a small private... Read More
Some time ago we had the privilege of working with... Read More
Want to bring out the best in people?Edward W. Smith,... Read More
Marriages and corporate mergers in America have at least one... Read More
"We are so different and individualistic that we can't work... Read More
The industrial age is over. Organizations still stuck in the... Read More
This article relates to the Recognition competency, commonly evaluated in... Read More
Creativity can be defined as problem identification and idea generation... Read More
Being able to give effective feedback is not just a... Read More
Have you unintentionally set your business up for failure?No one... Read More
Wouldn't it be nice for business owners and executives to... Read More
Leaders speak 15 to 20 times daily. You speak at... Read More
Mary Poppins describes a style of management which has for... Read More
AbstractThe electrical products industry is one characterized by fierce competition,... Read More
A major source of communication breakdowns is incongruence between the... Read More
I once was part of a group of management professors... Read More
A series of articles exploring the seven critical areas that... Read More
How can you get more attention for your conference and... Read More
I once worked with a developer who showed up at... Read More
IntroductionThe role of the Human Resource Manager is evolving with... Read More
THE MARGINAL PERFORMER: Every manager must, from time to time,... Read More
As a business owner, time is of the essence. Running... Read More
Are you uncomfortable with delivering disciplinary action, even involving employees... Read More
In a management role procrastination can seriously hold back progress... Read More
Imagine the following scenario - you pay a visit to... Read More
I personally struggle with the term 'managing people' - because... Read More
DISCUSSION METHODS: There are two basic types of discussion methods;... Read More
Check Out Your E-HabitsAnother week has ended. And, despite moving... Read More
How can you make the best use of your energy... Read More
In the call center environment we are often only as... Read More
Fast Relief for Sarbanes Oxley Section 404 ComplianceSection 404 of... Read More
[This article is based on excerpts from the special report... Read More
A major problem impairing an executive's performance is his Emotional... Read More
For you to get where you want to go, there... Read More
Meriwether Lewis set the stage for the Corps of Discovery's... Read More
Now that it is January, many of you are putting... Read More
It's clear to me that a workplace is a better... Read More
Business Management |