Car Insurance Monitoring for Discounted Insurance Rates - Privacy Devouring Monster Eating Us One Bi

For a price, would you let car insurer along for the ride? - asks a USA Today technology story by Kevin Maney. It seems that Progressive Insurance and IBM have worked out a scheme to pay drivers to be safer - by monitoring their every move in their own cars, and how fast they make that move, and where they park, and what time they drive.

The program is being tested in Minnesota and in the U.K. in a privacy busting program that rewards drivers for keeping under the maximum speed limits and driving during safer times of day. It's an interesting twist that is compared here to a shopper reward card that monitors what you buy, although it doesn't give you lower prices if you buy healthy food - which seems like the best analogy. (But it does let the food chains know how often you shop and how much you spend on what types of food, and alcohol, and cigarettes and trashy tabloids.)

Drivers must attach an electronic monitor to their cars that downloads information which is generated and stored there in diagnostic chips included in most newer model vehicles. As they drive, it stores current driving behavior - and location - and driving times and at the end of the defined time, drivers take the unit into the house, attach a USB cable and download that information into their computer and transmit it to Progressive.

But the insurance discount program does have an interesting twist in the Minnesota test. Apparently drivers who see from their downloaded information (or just know they drove badly at times) that they exceeded maximum speed limits, drove during expensive times (2am when bars close is most expensive, after 11pm is next) can choose NOT to send that information to Progressive and pay the normal undiscounted insurance rate.

It appears to have the true benefit of making drivers become more cautious and drive within limits of the law during safe hours. There is nothing wrong with this for those willing to give up the information. This allows those willing to be monitored the choice to send the information to their insurer and get a discount or NOT send it to pay normal rates. It's worth considering.

I'm among those who continues to use supermarket loyalty cards, even though I despise the fact that they can see my purchase history and note my travel habits. The savings are just too great to pass up. (I used a false name to set the card up, but quickly noted that they tied together my debit card name and loyalty card purchases, thus gaining that information that I had denied them with the false name - now I use cash.) You certainly can't do the same with the insurance driving discounts. Information must be accurate to properly insure and discount the policy.

The UK program is more invasive and offers far less choice. Drivers must always download the information from the car module to gain insurance discounts and the British company monitors more information from those UK drivers.

The US version may have some merit if choice remains a part of the equation upon full rollout to American drivers who want that ten percent discount on auto insurance policies in exchange for giving up the privacy of their driving habits.

The disturbing part of this, again, as always, is the possible merging of multiple databases to form near perfect surveillance pictures of us with each new development. Our supermarket discounts show that big database what we eat, what else we buy at the grocery, the insurance information defines our travels and schedule, our credit and debit card use defines our spending, travel and lifestyles, while multiple other databases from airline security info to phone records can be merged at any time to form near perfect pictures of our lives for anyone that wants to access it.

Once a national ID (driver licenses will soon carry mandatory magnetic information and will serve as a defacto national ID), we can be fully monitored, tracked, analyzed and digitized to form a truly invasive database of numbers and bits of information about each of us.

The sources of data about each of us are growing daily. The concern is the loss or abuse of that data through commercial and/or governmental negligence and/or criminal intent. The methods to access that data are growing as the sources proliferate.

Privacy is something we give up in small bits for small benefits, like cheaper produce using supermarket loyalty cards and insurance discounts using car monitors hooked up to our insurance carrier. We need laws to control and safegaurd each of those databases and stop any merging of those multiple sources of data into the ultimate Big Brother database.

I want my car insurance reduced and I'm willing to consider this newest scheme if I have choice of whether to send my info to my insurer. I will send it when I've been good and won't when I have been less good. But I don't want it merged with my other sources of data or shared among commercial interests who may see fit to sell it to each other.

It gets more interesting daily. Who is in control of this privacy devouring data monster?

Mike Banks Valentine blogs on privacy issues at: You can subscribe to the RSS feed by entering My Yahoo or My MSN at: Web Content Resource From

In The News:

pen paper and inkwell

cat break through

Car Insurance Quotes Online ? Why You Should Use the Internet to Find a New Insurance Company

Before the internet, you picked a neighborhood car insurance agent,... Read More

California Catering Truck Insurance

Catering truck insuranceNot many agents/brokers write catering truck insurance as... Read More

Is Life Insurance Comparison Really Necessary?

When you want to purchase a life insurance policy, you... Read More

Are You Overpaying On Your Home Insurance Policy?

For many consumers the cost of daily living is becoming... Read More

How Much Renters Insurance Do I Need?

When obtaining renter's insurance it is important to put serious... Read More

Six Ways to Cut the Cost of Your Auto Insurance

Is your auto insurance bill $12000 a year or even... Read More

Gain An Advantage Over Your Competition By Controlling The Cost Of Your Health Insurance

As many of us expect, the New Year will bring... Read More

UK Young Driver Motor Insurance - Build Your Own No Claims Bonus or Insure through Your Parents

For may young drivers, affording the costs of motor insurance... Read More

Mortgage Life Insurance

Owning a home is a dream for most of us,... Read More

Homeowners Insurance Coverage

When deciding on the appropriate amount of homeowner's insurance coverage... Read More

Do Insurance Premiums Increase Every Year?

Many people ask, "If I am supposed to get a... Read More

A Life Insurance Quote Became Reality

Life insurance quoteThank goodness John took his life insurance quote... Read More

5 Strategies To Reduce Your Car Insurance Premiums

Your latest car insurance bill has arrived and it is... Read More

Natures Fury - Time to Check Your Insurance

The communities of Exmouth and Moora in Western Australia don't... Read More

Dont Just Accept Your Car Insurance Renewal Quote

UK car insurance companies make substantial profits every year because... Read More

MSA or HSA: Can I Keep My MSA Or Do I Need to Convert it into an HSA?

The Medical Savings Account (MSA) is an older form of... Read More

UK House Insurance - The Risk of Under-insurance

For many years in the UK, motor insurance has been... Read More

Health Savings Account (HSA): Useful for Women in Childbearing Years?

The Health Savings Account (HSA) is an amazing tool that... Read More

How Does Credit History Affect Car Insurance Rates?

Many personal car insurance companies consider your credit information when... Read More

Term Life Insurance Quotes for Singles

Term life insurance quotes are rarely a concern of single... Read More

Independent Insurance Agents Unite! Insurance and Financial Discussion Forums are all the Rage

The online discussion forum has emerged as the medium of... Read More

Health Care and Health Insurance Costs Can Be Controlled Through Lifestyle Choices

As you probably know all to well, the cost of... Read More

Long Term Care Insurance How Much Should I Buy?

Long-term care insurance policies have a variety of features and... Read More

The Life Insurance Policy and Its Best Kept Secret

Do you love someone deeply enough to spend your hard... Read More

Term Life Insurance - A Safeguard for Small Business Owners

Term life insurance can offer protection for a small business... Read More

Senior Health Care Insurance

Health Insurance For Seniors On The NetWhen a good friend... Read More

Health Insurance Providers Online - Benefits to Applying Online

Health insurance providers are going online to find new customers.... Read More

Cheap Health Insurance - Health Insurance for The Self Employed

If you're self employed, you may think of health insurance... Read More

Do You Know What The 7 Home Insurance Plans Are?

Most people don't realize that there are 7 different homeowners... Read More

Is an HSA a Type of Insurance?

A Health Savings Account (HSA) is not a type of... Read More

Global Warming: Why Consumers and Insurers Are Getting Hot Under the Collar Over Life Insurance.

Global warming may have been lurking on our horizon for... Read More

What Price For Your Health?

How do you put a value good health? For many... Read More

Long Term Care Insurance

Long Term Care Insurance is needed in the event that... Read More