The Internet may have started as the fervent brainchild of DARPA, the US defence agency - but it quickly evolved into a network of computers at the service of a community. Academics around the world used it to communicate, compare results, compute, interact and flame each other. The ethos of the community as content-creator, source of information, fount of emotional sustenance, peer group, and social substitute is well embedded in the very fabric of the Net. Millions of members in free, advertising or subscription financed, mega-sites such as Geocities, AOL, Yahoo and Tripod generate more bits and bytes than the rest of the Internet combined. This traffic emanates from discussion groups, announcement (mailing) lists, newsgroups, and content sites (such as Suite101 and Webseed). Even the occasional visitor can find priceless gems of knowledge and opinion in the mound of trash and frivolity that these parts of the web have become.
The emergence of search engines and directories which cater only to this (sizeable) market segment was to be expected. By far the most comprehensive (and, thus, less discriminating) was Deja. It spidered and took in the exploding newsgroups (Usenet) scene with its tens of thousands of daily messages. When it was taken over by Google, its archives contained more than 500 million messages, cross-indexed every which way and pertaining to every possible (and many impossible) a topic.
Google is by far the most popular search engine yet, having surpassed the more veteran Northern Lights, Fast, and Alta Vista. Its mind defying database (more than 1.3 billion web pages), its caching technology (making it, in effect, one of the biggest libraries on earth) and its site ranking (by popularity and links-over) have rendered it unbeatable. Yet, its efforts to integrate the treasure trove that is Deja and adapt it to the Google search interface have hitherto been spectacularly unsuccessful (though it finally made it two and a half months after the purchase). So much so, that it gave birth to a protest movement.
http://groups.google.com/googlegroups/archive_announce.html
Bickering and bad tempered flaming (often bordering on the deranged, the racial, or the stalking) are the more repulsive aspects of the Usenet groups. But at the heart of the debate this time is no ordinary sadistic venting. The issue is: who owns content generated by the public at large on computers funded by tax dollars? Can a commercial enterprise own and monopolize the fruits of the collective effort of millions of individuals from all over the world? Or should such intellectual property remain in the public domain, perhaps maintained by public institutions (such as the Library of Congress)? Should open source movements gain access to Deja's source code in order to launch Deja II? And who owns the copyright to all these messages (theoretically, the authors)? Google, as Deja before it, is offering compilations of this content, the copyright to which it does not and cannot own. The very legal concept of intellectual property is at the crux of this virtual conflict.
Google was, thus, compelled to offer free access to the CONTENT of the Deja archives to alternative (non-Google) archiving systems. But it remains mum on the search programming code and the user interface. Already one such open source group (called Dela News) is coalescing, although it is not clear who will bear the costs of the gigantic storage and processing such a project would require. Dela wants to have a physical copy of the archive deposited in trust with a dot org.
This raises a host of no less fascinating subjects. The Deja Usenet search technology, programming code, and systems are inextricable and almost indistinguishable from the Usenet archive itself. Without these elements - structural as well as dynamic - there will be no archive and no way to extract meaningful information from the chaotic bedlam that is the Usenet environment. In this case, the information lies in the ordering and classification of raw data and not in the content itself. This is why the open source proponents demand that Google share both content and the tools to access it. Google's hasty and improvised unplugging of Deja in February only served to aggravate the die-hard fans of erstwhile Deja.
The Usenet is not only the refuge of pedophiles and neo-Nazis. It includes thousands of academically rigorous and research inclined discussion groups which morph with intellectual trends and fashionable subjects. More than twenty years of wisdom and erudition are buried in servers all over the world. Scholars often visit Usenet in their pursuit of complementary knowledge or expert advice. The Usenet is also the documentation of Western intellectual history in the last three decades. In it invaluable. Google's decision to abandon the internal links between Deja messages means the disintegration of the hyperlinked fabric of this resource - unless Google comes up with an alternative (and expensive) solution.
Google is offering a better, faster, more multi-layered and multi-faceted access to the entire archive. But its brush with the more abrasive side of the open source movement brought to the surface long suppressed issues. This may be the single most important contribution of this otherwise not so opportune transaction.
About The Author
Sam Vaknin is the author of "Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited" and "After the Rain - How the West Lost the East". He is a columnist in "Central Europe Review", United Press International (UPI) and ebookweb.org and the editor of mental health and Central East Europe categories in The Open Directory, Suite101 and searcheurope.com. Until recently, he served as the Economic Advisor to the Government of Macedonia.
His web site: http://samvak.tripod.com
Since search engines are the first stop for people on... Read More
Internet surfers use search engines more than any other tool... Read More
Search Engine Optimization (SEO) must be considered a process and... Read More
Listen. Some make submitting pages to search engines sound like... Read More
If you would like to know when your site was... Read More
For your web site to succeed, you must use is... Read More
Duplicate content penalty. Ever heard of it? This penalty is... Read More
Want to drive more targeted traffic to your web site?Want... Read More
In order to tap the huge stream of targeted traffic... Read More
Okay I admit it. I was kidding. I can't guarantee... Read More
So you have a beautiful website that you paid a... Read More
Search engines determine their rankings based on two things: ... Read More
Search engine optimization this and search engine optimization that. You... Read More
One of my favorite subjects to teach on at our... Read More
Google's calling your name...Hi, Google here. We want to index... Read More
With all the recent publicity given to Google as the... Read More
I hear this all the time. "I can get you... Read More
Before you make drastic changes to your website after a... Read More
You built that content rich web page optimized for your... Read More
Over the past few years, there have been many debates... Read More
As we all know Google uses their PageRank technology to... Read More
Since the last Google update, there have been many instances... Read More
In efforts to increase sales and profitability, more and more... Read More
Google uses PageRank to rank your pages. To maximize your... Read More
Google Sitemaps enables Webmasters to Directly Alert Google to Changes... Read More
I don't know about you, but I felt a lot... Read More
One of the most overlooked strategies to improve search engine... Read More
If you are confused about terms like "search engine optimization"... Read More
Web users turn to search engines for answers to their... Read More
Every website has times when traffic is higher than others.... Read More
"Owning your business category online is more than just a... Read More
Does Creating a Google Site Map and Telling Google About... Read More
Trying to improve search engine rankings is just like a... Read More
With the help of MSN, recently I've been reminiscing about... Read More
Increasing your search engine rankings should certainly be one of... Read More
Google is the undisputed heavyweight champion of search engines. Most... Read More
By Catherine FranzSearch engine spiders read and record page titles... Read More
In my previous article, I raised the issue that proper... Read More
RSS is the latest craze in online publishing. But what... Read More
Woaah! Wait a minute. Before I exclusively reveal these insider... Read More
Everyone wants to increase their rankings with the search engines... Read More
It is literally amazing how many people start their online... Read More
The most difficult challenge most web designers face is getting... Read More
Keyword analysis is a major part of search engine marketing.... Read More
Think you know everything about searching with Google? Think again.... Read More
When it comes to promoting your website, you might think... Read More
In order that someone finds your website and buys your... Read More
Get Indexed FastWhat does getting indexed mean?The search engines keep... Read More
A very provocative title, isn't it? Based on the latest... Read More
In October 2002, the Yahoo! portal changed the way it... Read More
There has been a good deal written about the Google... Read More
Search Engine OptimizationSearch engines still remain the #1 tool to... Read More
Lately, there have been a lot of heated discussions regarding... Read More
Internal Linking ? An introductionThe web as they call it... Read More
Everyone knows that if your website has a high Google... Read More
Whether you want to start a business and sell on... Read More
Online search giant, Google, often tests the waters for new... Read More
The following are a list of mistakes can ensure that... Read More
After 105 days Google finally updated PR. And it's about... Read More
Yesterday you should have read the second course out of... Read More
Often, sites view seo and PPC marketing as exclusive marketing... Read More
News broke this week that Yahoo has purchased the Inktomi... Read More
Here are some observations that I have made recently:1. On... Read More
I had an email "conversation" this last week which I... Read More
Sitemaps are without doubt one of the most often ignored... Read More
Getting your website listed in the search engines is relatively... Read More
Search Engine Optimization (SEO) |