As senior pastor of the First Presbyterian Church of New York, Fosdick preached a sermon one Sunday in 1922 that aroused the righteous indignation of fundamentalists and he suddenly found himself at the center of a heated theological controversy. In order to understand the tension that existed between fundamentalism and modernism, it is necessary that I briefly delineate the fundamentalist position at that time.
Fundamentalism is a rather broad movement within Protestanism which claims the absolute inerrancy of the words of the Holy Bible. It attempts to preserve what is considered to be the fundamental ideas of Christianity against criticism by liberal theologians. Bishop Pike noted that the fundamentalist regarded any particular assertion or narrative in the Scriptures that is challenged, qualified, or treated as myth; any attempt to rethink and restate the verities to which the Bible witnesses, fundamentalists suspects of infidelity and unbelief (A Time for Christian Candor).
Between 1909 and 1915, anonymous authors published twelve small volumes entitles, The Fundamentals. Millions of copies were distributed to various religious organizations and institutions. I believe it was about 85 or 90 articles that were written for the series with at least 30 devoted to the issue of biblical authority. The spirit of the work coincided with the spirit of early fundamentalism ? calm, determined, intending merely the reaffirmation of what was perceived as fundamental truths. It was from the title of the publication that the movement got its name.
The primary doctrines that the fundamentalist thought should be accepted without challenge were:
1) The inspiration and infallibility of the Bible.
2) The doctrine of the Trinity.
3) The Virgin birth and deity of Christ.
4) The substitutionary theory of the atonement, and
5) The bodily resurrection, ascension, and the second coming of Christ.
To a large extent, fundamentalism was a reactionary movement. It reacted against the prevailing intellectualism which was increasingly attracting the modern world's attention. Liberal scholars challenged biblical authority; utilized historical research to question previously accepted Christian doctrines and their influence was beginning to be felt very strongly in schools, seminaries and churches. And if that wasn't enough, in addition to the growing strength of liberalism, Darwin and Spencer's evolutionary theories began to be used to discredit orthodoxy's theory of the origin of man. Consequently, firmly convinced that the Bible was being destroyed by liberalism and that the fundamentals of the Christian faith were not properly being taught in seminaries, fundamentalism rose to reassert the basics of Christian doctrines.
So, it is clear that the flames between the fundamentalist and modernists had existed for some time, but Fosdick, perhaps unwittingly; perhaps not, added fuel to the fire when he preached his controversial sermon, "Shall the Fundamentalist Win?" According to Fosdick, the sermon was intended as a plea for church tolerance that would allow for a diversity of theological view points. But the Fundamentalists took it as a personal assault and they subsequently, counter-attacked. They made it their business to become more publicly visible. They began publishing newspapers and magazines that leaned toward their religious philosophy, established missions, and erected their own schools and seminaries. In other words, Fundamentalists courageously rose to firmly reassert orthodoxy over and against the claims of liberalism.
In regards to the outcome for Fosdick, by 1923 the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (to a great extent influenced by William Jennings Bryan), adopted a resolution asking the Presbytery of New York to insist that Fosdick accept full membership into the Presbyterian fold and to conform to the Presbyterian system of doctrines. Fosdick rejected those terms and even though the Presbyterians tried to work out an agreeable compromise, the controversy became so heated and intense and for Fosdick personally insulting, that he resigned and preached his last sermon at First Presbyterian Church some time during the early months of 1925.
It appears that during early twentieth century, liberal influence began to wane. Following the depression of 1929, a mood of disillusionment settled over the land and man at best felt lost. What could optimistic liberalism say to the modern man of twentieth century to rebuild his faith? Philosophies such as positivism and naturalism became fashionable but were unfriendly towards liberalism. As Hordern stated, "the Bible became a problem for liberals. For one thing, if the truth of the Bible is only that which we can experience in more modern categories, and which we can know by reason, why bother with the Bible at all?" Unfortunately, liberals did not have satisfying answers. Even Fosdick himself later admitted that modernism, in and of itself was not enough. He came to believe that liberal theology had to do more than accommodate itself to the times or it would become shallow and transient.;
1) A preoccupation with intellectualism
2) It was dangerously sentimental
3) It tended to water down the concept of God and adjust itself to a man-centered culture and
4) It lost its ethical standing ground and its ability to launch a moral attack.
These criticisms along with many, many others helped to decrease liberalism's influence and impact upon the modern world.
Liberalism however, is by no means dead. Its concern for relevance has continued to grow and many liberal theologians are currently absorbed in the serious study of hermeneutical difficulties. Liberalism has undergone many changes and made substantial modifications of its former theological stance. We appear to be presently living in an age of Neo-liberalism. But the basic affirmations underlying liberal thought continues to be their stress on the importance of the inductive method of inquiry which was proving to be so successful for progress in other areas of human endeavor; their reliance upon experience, not the Bible, s the primary authority, their stress on continuity between God and humanity, reason and revelation, and their emphasis on human potential to overcome personal inadequacies and the shortcomings of the social order.
Last Word
We have surveyed the historical context out of which liberal theology emerged and the dominant characters and ideas disclosed in its development. Liberalism gradually grew out of Protestant orthodoxy. Great philosophers such as Spinoza, Hume and Kant played important roles and laid the building blocks which later scholars built upon, but the process was slow and not a radical departure from traditional Christianity. Though I tried to specify certain time periods in which one phase of liberal was dominant, it should be understood that there is no definite point in the history of liberalism at which a decisive break with the past can be clearly discerned.
Liberalism's religious position has always been in the process of evolving yet continuous with what has always been central and valuable in their Christian heritage.
Rev. Saundra L. Washington, D.D., is an ordained clergywoman, veteran social worker, and Founder of AMEN Ministries. She is also the author of two coffee table books: Room Beneath the Snow: Poems that Preach and Negative Disturbances: Homilies that Teach which can be reviewed on her site. Her new book, Out of Deep Waters: My Grief Management Workbook, is expected to be available in July.
You are welcome to visit AMEN Ministries: Your Soul's Service Station for spiritual refreshing, soul edification or to browse our newly expanded mini shopping mall.
Blessings to all!
It is written in Revelation 1:1 The revelation of Jesus... Read More
It is written in Proverbs 14:2 There is a way... Read More
This is the event that has already occurred. In 70... Read More
IT IS WRITTEN. Satanic Panic and the Alien Connection -... Read More
Amos was a shepherd who lived in the region of... Read More
Apology:I don't for a minute profess to know what God... Read More
One of my favorite stories in the Bible is the... Read More
Recently I met an interesting Gentleman at a Coffee Shop,... Read More
Hermeneutics is the science and art of the interpretive process... Read More
I am with you heart and mind..."Do all that you... Read More
Are we doing what the word of God say to... Read More
Most people put a lot of effort into being like... Read More
The purposes of a man's heart are deep waters, but... Read More
Once upon a time, Americans traveled the highways searching for... Read More
Thumbing through Isaiah recently I was startled to find this:... Read More
For those of you who have entered into a true... Read More
If you look at just the man/women after he/she has... Read More
Vardhamana Mahavira, the 24th Tirthankara of Jainism was the last... Read More
I was meditating the other day and contemplating the thousands... Read More
You all know the big dogs that carry rum to... Read More
There is a sharp contrast in Ephesians between the "light"... Read More
As believers, we have a responsibility to care for those... Read More
Buddhism is a teaching which has spread worldwide absorbing the... Read More
The thought of a public examination before the Judgment bar... Read More
The Rapture of the Church will be the most startling... Read More
There is a great need in the world today for... Read More
It's Saturday night. You're sitting at home. Your phone has... Read More
Using a good tool over and over doesn't make it... Read More
The story of Joshua and Caleb is one of the... Read More
Dear Readers, I received a letter this week that is... Read More
AFTERLIFE: The 'Bardol Thodol' and 'Sidpa Thodol' of the Tibetan... Read More
1 Corinthians 9:19-9:23From The Heart A Look at Christianity from... Read More
The bible tells a story about the prophet Ezekiel who... Read More
Most of know how Jesus was crucified. Do we ever... Read More
What will be the effect on general public if the... Read More
One day on the listserve for my support group it... Read More
"Therefore I do not run like a man... Read More
We are all very well aware of the tragedies occurring... Read More
As you will see in the Scripture verses I will... Read More
Small BeginningsMy first experience in music ministry happened fairly soon... Read More
The Dead Sea Scrolls continue to be found and there... Read More
Amos was summoned by God to warn the Northern Kingdom... Read More
There's another "move of God" that's sweeping the nations. Have... Read More
Follow me, and I will make you fishers of men."... Read More
Stories have been told about the only thing that saved... Read More
Many cities have large Catholic Church presence and well-established Lutheran... Read More
"What? Trying to spread the gospel message without quoting from... Read More
The subject of this document is so unpleasing to the... Read More
Although I've never met Supreme Court nominee John Roberts, I... Read More
Gay marriage is hitting significant resistance in Washington D.C. where... Read More
"Your focus determines your reality", this famous line was spoken... Read More
As I am sure you all can tell by now,... Read More
Matthew 24:34-24:35 Verily I say unto you, This generation shall... Read More
If you say that Christianity is a peaceful religion according... Read More
Let's be honest: Too many Christian books are nothing but... Read More
The first issue we must recognize is the way God... Read More
The London Bombings are just the beginning. Londoners are probably... Read More
I think most people who will read this will not... Read More
Christian books and supplies can be found at places that... Read More
The major themes of the Hebrew Bible (also known... Read More
The new Pope is not expected to break ranks with... Read More
We all must know that the Catholic Church has used... Read More
This is to my Father's glory, that you bear much... Read More
Upon the death of the Pope, a monumental sequence of... Read More
To be awakened to the realization of one's True Self... Read More
The flesh is the part of us that resists our... Read More
Religion |