Storytelling has been with us since the days of campfire and besieging wild animals. It served a number of important functions: amelioration of fears, communication of vital information (regarding survival tactics and the characteristics of animals, for instance), the satisfaction of a sense of order (justice), the development of the ability to hypothesize, predict and introduce theories and so on.
We are all endowed with a sense of wonder. The world around us in inexplicable, baffling in its diversity and myriad forms. We experience an urge to organize it, to "explain the wonder away", to order it in order to know what to expect next (predict). These are the essentials of survival. But while we have been successful at imposing our mind's structures on the outside world ? we have been much less successful when we tried to cope with our internal universe.
The relationship between the structure and functioning of our (ephemeral) mind, the structure and modes of operation of our (physical) brain and the structure and conduct of the outside world have been the matter of heated debate for millennia. Broadly speaking, there were (and still are) two ways of treating it:
There were those who, for all practical purposes, identified the origin (brain) with its product (mind). Some of them postulated the existence of a lattice of preconceived, born categorical knowledge about the universe ? the vessels into which we pour our experience and which mould it. Others have regarded the mind as a black box. While it was possible in principle to know its input and output, it was impossible, again in principle, to understand its internal functioning and management of information. Pavlov coined the word "conditioning", Watson adopted it and invented "behaviourism", Skinner came up with "reinforcement". The school of epiphenomenologists (emergent phenomena) regarded the mind as the by product of the brain's "hardware" and "wiring" complexity. But all ignored the psychophysical question: what IS the mind and HOW is it linked to the brain?
The other camp was more "scientific" and "positivist". It speculated that the mind (whether a physical entity, an epiphenomenon, a non-physical principle of organization, or the result of introspection) ? had a structure and a limited set of functions. They argued that a "user's manual" could be composed, replete with engineering and maintenance instructions. The most prominent of these "psychodynamists" was, of course, Freud. Though his disciples (Adler, Horney, the object-relations lot) diverged wildly from his initial theories ? they all shared his belief in the need to "scientify" and objectify psychology. Freud ? a medical doctor by profession (Neurologist) and Bleuler before him ? came with a theory regarding the structure of the mind and its mechanics: (suppressed) energies and (reactive) forces. Flow charts were provided together with a method of analysis, a mathematical physics of the mind.
But this was a mirage. An essential part was missing: the ability to test the hypotheses, which derived from these "theories". They were all very convincing, though, and, surprisingly, had great explanatory power. But - non-verifiable and non-falsifiable as they were ? they could not be deemed to possess the redeeming features of a scientific theory.
Deciding between the two camps was and is a crucial matter. Consider the clash - however repressed - between psychiatry and psychology. The former regards "mental disorders" as euphemisms - it acknowledges only the reality of brain dysfunctions (such as biochemical or electric imbalances) and of hereditary factors. The latter (psychology) implicitly assumes that something exists (the "mind", the "psyche") which cannot be reduced to hardware or to wiring diagrams. Talk therapy is aimed at that something and supposedly interacts with it.
But perhaps the distinction is artificial. Perhaps the mind is simply the way we experience our brains. Endowed with the gift (or curse) of introspection, we experience a duality, a split, constantly being both observer and observed. Moreover, talk therapy involves TALKING - which is the transfer of energy from one brain to another through the air. This is directed, specifically formed energy, intended to trigger certain circuits in the recipient brain. It should come as no surprise if it were to be discovered that talk therapy has clear physiological effects upon the brain of the patient (blood volume, electrical activity, discharge and absorption of hormones, etc.).
All this would be doubly true if the mind was, indeed, only an emergent phenomenon of the complex brain - two sides of the same coin.
Psychological theories of the mind are metaphors of the mind. They are fables and myths, narratives, stories, hypotheses, conjunctures. They play (exceedingly) important roles in the psychotherapeutic setting ? but not in the laboratory. Their form is artistic, not rigorous, not testable, less structured than theories in the natural sciences. The language used is polyvalent, rich, effusive, and fuzzy ? in short, metaphorical. They are suffused with value judgements, preferences, fears, post facto and ad hoc constructions. None of this has methodological, systematic, analytic and predictive merits.
Still, the theories in psychology are powerful instruments, admirable constructs of the mind. As such, they are bound to satisfy some needs. Their very existence proves it.
The attainment of peace of mind is a need, which was neglected by Maslow in his famous rendition. People will sacrifice material wealth and welfare, will forgo temptations, will ignore opportunities, and will put their lives in danger ? just to reach this bliss of wholeness and completeness. There is, in other words, a preference of inner equilibrium over homeostasis. It is the fulfilment of this overriding need that psychological theories set out to cater to. In this, they are no different than other collective narratives (myths, for instance).
In some respects, though, there are striking differences:
Psychology is desperately trying to link up to reality and to scientific discipline by employing observation and measurement and by organizing the results and presenting them using the language of mathematics. This does not atone for its primordial sin: that its subject matter is ethereal and inaccessible. Still, it lends an air of credibility and rigorousness to it.
The second difference is that while historical narratives are "blanket" narratives ? psychology is "tailored", "customized". A unique narrative is invented for every listener (patient, client) and he is incorporated in it as the main hero (or anti-hero). This flexible "production line" seems to be the result of an age of increasing individualism. True, the "language units" (large chunks of denotates and connotates) are one and the same for every "user". In psychoanalysis, the therapist is likely to always employ the tripartite structure (Id, Ego, Superego). But these are language elements and need not be confused with the plots. Each client, each person, and his own, unique, irreplicable, plot.
To qualify as a "psychological" plot, it must be:
In all these respects, a psychological plot is a theory in disguise. Scientific theories should satisfy most of the same conditions. But the equation is flawed. The important elements of testability, verifiability, refutability, falsifiability, and repeatability ? are all missing. No experiment could be designed to test the statements within the plot, to establish their truth-value and, thus, to convert them to theorems.
There are four reasons to account for this shortcoming:
So, what are plots good for? They are the instruments used in the procedures, which induce peace of mind (even happiness) in the client. This is done with the help of a few embedded mechanisms:
About The Author
Sam Vaknin is the author of "Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited" and the editor of mental health categories in The Open Directory, Suite101, and searcheurope.com.
His web site: http://samvak.tripod.com
Frequently asked questions regarding narcissism: http://samvak.tripod.com/faq1.html
Narcissistic Personality Disorder on Suite101: http://www.suite101.com/welcome.cfm/npd
Ever felt urged to steal a piece of bubblegum from... Read More
Feelings and emotions are nerve impulses.The feel of paper and... Read More
How exactly is the Human Psyche effected by the trivial... Read More
Do you know anyone who always wins? Sure you know... Read More
American schools have traditionally favored those students who excel in... Read More
The bodies natural clock or circadian rhythm seems to have... Read More
Evidence of hypnotic-like phenomena appears in many ancient cultures. The... Read More
There's so much talk about emotional intelligence and how it... Read More
Even though hypnosis has been around officially since the 1700s... Read More
It's important to know that Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and... Read More
Schizophrenics hallucinate alternate realities. People who claim to have been... Read More
What does it mean to be Human? Well if you... Read More
Even though the percentage of people with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity... Read More
Much of the time when a new idea comes to... Read More
STUDY STRATEGIES* Revise regularly- Revision should be continuous if you... Read More
WHAT ARE BRAINWAVES?Every moment of your life your brain is... Read More
Anti-social behaviors are common with ADHD individuals. About 60% of... Read More
Individuals with a solid working knowledge of Controlled Remote Viewing... Read More
All of us suffer from some form of emotional distress... Read More
Sometimes I think that I have a mental health problem... Read More
Upon being diagnosed with Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder, I saw the reality... Read More
In two articles entitled "We Are Not Our Personalities" and... Read More
There is one place in which one's privacy, intimacy, integrity... Read More
Incest is not such a clear-cut matter as it has... Read More
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder is a neurologically based disorder. This... Read More
The endless, immeasurable brain. It does seem like more we... Read More
Every child who is adopted from foster care deserves a... Read More
After a long and patient wait in queue, you reached... Read More
Solution Talk vs. Problem TalkProblem talk, of course, is talk... Read More
The issue of self-esteem is perhaps one of the greatest... Read More
Self hypnosis is usually thought of as a person listening... Read More
Trust is the basis of all human relationships. Trust can... Read More
Do all personality disorders have a common psychodynamic source?To what... Read More
When the brain is asleep and in REM dream mode... Read More
Howard Gardner's theory of multiple intelligences is based on the... Read More
Repeated research studies have revealed that secular efforts at rehabilitation... Read More
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder is a neurologically based disorder. This... Read More
Solution Focus is the brain child of Insoo Kim Berg... Read More
Sometimes I think that I have a mental health problem... Read More
Evidence of hypnotic-like phenomena appears in many ancient cultures. The... Read More
THE ACTS OF CREATION:The following quote is a review I... Read More
Gay men are said to be usually third or further... Read More
How do we treat bipolar disorder? Specifically, how do we... Read More
The word "cognition" is defined as "the act of knowing"... Read More
Solution Talk vs. Problem TalkProblem talk, of course, is talk... Read More
Ever felt urged to steal a piece of bubblegum from... Read More
To the narcissist, the Internet is an alluring and irresistible... Read More
When Marcus and Sally first met they immediately felt like... Read More
Howard Gardner's theory of multiple intelligences developed as he worked... Read More
Swedish Scientists did a study and found that young men... Read More
Self hypnosis is usually thought of as a person listening... Read More
It's important to know that Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and... Read More
Trust is the basis of all human relationships. Trust can... Read More
The Olympic Contests for Synchronized Swimming are a testament to... Read More
Over the past 10 years I have helped individuals who... Read More
Storytelling has been with us since the days of campfire... Read More
Random thought Sequence in the Human Mind. I want to... Read More
Individuals with a solid working knowledge of Controlled Remote Viewing... Read More
Anti-social behaviors are common with ADHD individuals. About 60% of... Read More
The Encyclopaedia Britannica (1999 edition) defines empathy as:"The ability to... Read More
Alzheimer's Dementia has a combination of cognitive and behavioral manifestations.... Read More
When does consciousness exist? Will the sentient robots being created... Read More
Most narcissists (75%) are men.NPD is one of a "family"... Read More
The following good work from a person engaged in trying... Read More
It is crucial that interviewing with helpee progress toward solutions.... Read More
IntroductionDeveloping healthy peer relationships is critical for the normal development... Read More
Psychology |