Being critical of Buddhism isn't easy.
Buddhism is the most likable of the major religions, and Buddhists are the perennial good guys of modern spirituality. Beautiful traditions, lovely architecture, inspiring statuary, ancient history, the Dalai Lama - what's not to like?
Everything about Buddhsim is just so... nice. No fatwahs or jihads, no inquisitions or crusades, no terrorists or pederasts, just nice people being nice. In fact, Buddhism means niceness. Nice-ism.
At least, it should.
Buddha means Awakened One, so Buddhism can be taken to mean Awake-ism. Awakism. It would therefore be natural to think that if you were looking to wake up, then Buddhism, i.e., Awakism, would be the place to look.
::: The Light is Better Over Here
Such thinking, however, would reveal a dangerous lack of respect for the opposition. Maya, goddess of delusion, has been doing her job with supreme mastery since the first spark of self-awareness flickered in some chimp's noggin, and the idea that the neophyte truth-seeker can just sign up with the Buddhists, read some books, embrace some new concepts and slam her to the mat might be a bit on the naive side.
On the other hand, why not? How'd this get so turned around? It's just truth. Shouldn't truth be, like, the simplest thing? Shouldn't someone who wants to find something as ubiquitous as truth be able to do so? And here's this venerable organization supposedly dedicated to just that very thing, even named for it, so what's the problem?
::: Why doesn't Buddhism produce Buddhas?
The problem arises from the fact that Buddhists, like everyone else, insist on reconciling the irreconcilable. They don't just want to awaken to the true, they also want to make sense of the untrue. They want to have their cake and eat it too, so they end up with nonsensical theories, divergent schools, sagacious doubletalk, and zero Buddhas.
Typical of Buddhist insistence on reconciling the irreconcilable is the concept of Two Truths, a poignant two-word joke they don't seem to get, and yet this sort of perversely irrational thinking is at the very heart of the failed search for truth. We don't want truth, we want a particular truth; one that doesn't threaten ego, one that doesn't exist. We insist on a truth that makes sense given what we know, not knowing that we don't know anything.
Nothing about Buddhism is more revealing than the Four Noble Truths which, not being true, are of pretty dubious nobility. They form the basis of Buddhism, so it's clear from the outset that the Buddhists have whipped up a proprietary version of truth shaped more by market forces than any particular concern for the less consumer-friendly, albeit true, truth.
Yes, Buddhism may be spiritually filling, even nourishing, but insofar as truth is concerned, it's junkfood. You can eat it every day of your life and die exactly as Awakened as the day you signed up.
::: Bait & Switch
Buddhism is a classic bait-and-switch operation. We're attracted by the enlightenment in the window, but as soon as we're in the door they start steering us over to the compassion aisle. Buddhists could be honest and change their name to Compassionism, but who wants that?
There's the rub. They can't sell compassion and they can't deliver enlightenment.
This untruth-in-advertising is the kind of game you have to play if you want to stay successful in a business where the customer is always wrong. You can either go out of business honestly, or thrive by giving the people what they want. What they say they want and what they really want, though, are two very different things.
::: Me Me Me
To the outside observer, much of Buddhist knowledge and practice seems focused on spiritual self-improvement. This, too, is hard to speak against... except within the context of awakening from delusion. Then it's easy.
There is no such thing as true self, so any pursuit geared toward its aggrandizement, betterment, upliftment, elevation, evolution, glorification, salvation, etc, is utter folly. How much more so any endeavor undertaken merely to increase one's own happiness or contentment or, I'm embarrassed to even say it, bliss?
Self is ego and ego is the realm of the dreamstate. If you want to break free of the dreamstate, you must break free of self, not stroke it to make it purr or groom it for some imagined brighter future.
::: Maya's House of Enlightenment
The trick with being critical of so esteemed and beloved an institution is not to get dragged down into the morass of details and debate. It's very simple: If Buddhism is about enlightenment, people should be getting enlightened. If it's not about enlightenment, they should change the sign.
Of course, Buddhism isn't completely unique in its survival tactics. This same gulf between promise and performance is found in all systems of human spirituality. We're looking at it in Buddhism because that's where it's most pronounced. No disrespect to the Buddha is intended. If there was a Buddha and he was enlightened, then it's Buddhism that insults his memory, not healthy skepticism. Blame the naked emperor's retinue of tailors and lickspittles, not the boy who merely states the obvious.
Buddhism is arguably the most elevated of man's great belief systems. If you want to enjoy the many valuable benefits it has to offer, then I wouldn't presume to utter a syllable against it. But if you want to escape from the clutches of Maya, then I suggest you take a very close look at the serene face on all those golden statues to see if it isn't really hers.
::: About the Author
"Jed McKenna is an American original." -Lama Surya Das
Jed McKenna is the author of "Spiritual Enlightenment: The Damnedest Thing" and "Spiritually Incorrect Enlightenment", published by Wisefool Press. Coming in 2005: "Spirituality X" and "Jed McKenna's Notebook". Visit http://www.WisefoolPress.com to learn more.
I would like to share my experience, working with the... Read More
The chakras are different coloured energy centres that originate from... Read More
To understand the nature of esoteric and occult secrets it... Read More
"Spirit is beyond the void of space. This realm, beyond... Read More
"A common jar of clay can never become a noble... Read More
The Many Waters explores the universe and sifts through the... Read More
No, I have never seen a fairy, an angel, nor... Read More
The words 'new age' and 'spirituality' can have people running... Read More
According to H. G. Bosch, the newspaper cartoonist H. T.... Read More
Self-actualization comes down to three basic premises: this is who... Read More
Before we dwell on the subject of Self Realization we... Read More
The question isn't, "Is there life after death."Rather, the question... Read More
Uh, oh. I'm in trouble now. I found God. Now... Read More
Military personnel at a U.S. prison in Guantanamo, Bay, Cuba... Read More
On reading Susan Cato's Time Magazine Canada piece titled, "In... Read More
In the spring of 2003, I spent three weeks in... Read More
Although spring is just around the corner, there have been... Read More
Angels, those divine beings of love and light, are here... Read More
The concept of integrity has arisen often in discussions of... Read More
Most of our troubles are bought about by exercising our... Read More
Recently, I received a postcard from Ireland. Without reading the... Read More
Many of our great religions hold that numbers contain hidden... Read More
The first hymn of Isha Upanishad says - whatever living... Read More
Most of us think of what a wonderful world this... Read More
The Word became flesh and made his dwelling among us.... Read More
There is light at the end of the tunnel, but... Read More
I was walking down the street the other day, walking... Read More
Sometimes showing up for life can seem like a major... Read More
Last NAN I explained how to petition the female Saints... Read More
An interesting question that frequently comes up is "Which Gods... Read More
While there are alot of warnings and admonishments regarding what... Read More
A lot of times when I am reading people on... Read More
Ecclesiasts 5:18 Then I realized that it is good and... Read More
People have always sought the sacred. It is the Divine... Read More
The deeper beauty of spring is its process. In winter's... Read More
The first gospel written by Matthew,who is Levi, is the... Read More
WOW ... what a question. But today, while I was... Read More
Your mind-body team is made up of your mind and... Read More
For some of us, spirituality is considered a religion, and... Read More
I honestly am not sure why this hit me so... Read More
Greetings Divine Ones, I am going to ask you a... Read More
"Here I am! I stand at the door and knock.... Read More
When the Tsunami struck Asia and East Africa on December... Read More
Throughout history, what is portrayed in all religions as being... Read More
My thoughts can get a little edgy at night. Possibly... Read More
The normal Aquarian preoccupation with rational science is clearly seen... Read More
Michael Shermer speaks with the energy and passion of an... Read More
It was my intention to explain the word "simple," and... Read More
We desire to understand the world by giving names to... Read More
What better example than Jesus' life to explain about having... Read More
â??Now is the time for all good men to come... Read More
It seems more people today are using the Christian god... Read More
The still place is the beginning. Settle in there, ask... Read More
AN ARISTOCRATIC UPBRINGING:There are many people who write about sex... Read More
Matthew 3:1-3 The Preaching of John the Baptist1 In those... Read More
You're looking at one star in the middle of a... Read More
Continued from "Origin of Certain Thoughts, Part I"If you haven't... Read More
I finally went to the dentist today. I had been... Read More
I do not want curiosity seekers, who come for a... Read More
A new chapter in my life begins today, the anniversary... Read More
The smart 'spiritual' answer is 'you always get what you... Read More
There is a concept in Jewish mystical thought known as... Read More
Natural laws exist that serve to maintain order in the... Read More
Far to many people have become "followers" rather than BEING... Read More
An interesting question that frequently comes up is "Which Gods... Read More
It will all be clear in a minute, but first... Read More
Spirituality |