What do they do? How do they work? Which one is right for me? By Alan Hearnshaw
Spam is a very real problem that many people have to deal with on a daily basis. For those that have decided to do something about it and start to investigate the options available in spam filtering, this article provides a brief introduction to your options and the types of spam filters available.
Despite the bewildering array of spam filters available today, all claiming to the best one "of its kind" there are really just five filtering methodologies in general use today and all products rely on one, or a combination of these:
Content-Based Filters
"In the beginning, there were content-based filters."
These filters scan the contents of the and look for tell-tale signs that the message is spam. In the early days of spamming it was quite simple to look out for "Kill Words" such as "Lose Weight" and mark a message as spam if it was found.
Very soon though, spammers got wise to this and started resorting to all kinds of tricks to get their message past the filters. The days of "obfuscation" had begun. We started getting messages containing the phrase "L0se Welght" (Notice the zero for "o" and "l" for "i") and even more bizarre ? and sometimes quite ingenious ? variations.
This rendered basic content-based filters somewhat ineffective, although there are one or two on the market now that are clever enough to "see through" theses attempts and still provide good results.
Bayesian Based Filters
"The Reverend Bayes comes to the rescue"
Born in London 1702, the son of a minister, Thomas Bayes developed a formula which allowed him to determine the probability of an event occurring based on the probabilities of two or more independent evidentiary events.
Bayesian filters "learn" from studying known good and bad messages. Each message is split into single "word bytes", or tokens and these tokens are placed into a database along with how often they are found in each kind of message.
When a new message arrives to be tested by the filter, the new message is also split into tokens and each token is looked up in the database. Extrapolating results from the database and applying a form of the good reverend's formula, know as the a "Naive Bayesian" formula, the message is given a "spamicity" rating and can be dealt with accordingly.
Bayesian filters typically are capable of achieving very good accuracy rates (>97% is not uncommon), and require very little on-going maintenance.
Whitelist/Blacklist Filters
"Who goes there, friend or foe?"
This very basic form of filtering is seldom used on its own nowadays, but can be useful as part of a larger filtering strategy.
A "whitelist" is nothing more than a list of e-mail addresses from which you wish to accept communications. A whitelist filter would only accept messages from these people and all others would be rejected
A "blacklist", conversely, is a list of e-mail addresses - and sometimes IP Addresses (computer identification addresses) - from which communications will not be accepted.
While this may seem like a good idea from the outset, a whitelist methodology is too restrictive for most people and, as virtually all spam e-mails carry a forged "from" address, there is little point in collecting this address to ban it in future as it is very unlikely to be the same next time.
There are bodies on the internet that maintain a list of known "bad" sources of e-mail. Many filters today have the ability to query these servers to see if the message they are looking at comes from a source identified by this Internet-based blacklist, or RBL. While being quite effective, they do tend to suffer from "false positives" where good messages are incorrectly identified as spam. This happens often with newsletters.
Challenge/Response Filters
"Open sesame!"
Challenge/Response filters are characterised by their ability to automatically send a response to a previously unknown sender asking them to take some further action before their message will be delivered. This is often referred to as a "Turing Test" - named after a test devised by British mathematician Alan Turing to determine if machines could "think".
Recent years have seen the appearance of some internet services which automatically perform this Challenge/Response function for the user and require the sender of an e-mail to visit their web site to facilitate the receipt of their message.
Critics of this system claim it to be too drastic a measure and that it sends a message that "my time is more important than yours" to the people trying to communicate with you.
For some low traffic e-mail users though, this system alone may be a perfectly acceptable method of completely eliminating spam from their inbox - one step above the "Whitelist" system outlined above.
Community Filters
"A united front"
These types of filters work on the principal of "communal knowledge" of spam. When a user receives a spam message, they simply mark it as such in their filter. This information is sent to a central server where a "fingerprint" of the message is stored.
After enough people have "voted" this message to be spam, then it is stopped from reaching all the other people in the community.
This type of filtering can prove to be quite effective, although it stands to reason that it can never be 100% effective as a few people have to receive the spam for it to be "flagged" in the first place. Just like its similar cousin the Internet black list (RBL), this system also can suffer from "false positives", or messages incorrectly identified as spam.
Hopefully you are now armed with a little more information to be able to make an informed decision on the best spam filter for you.
For further information, consider reading the reviews and articles found at http://www.whichspamfilter.com
Alan Hearnshaw is a computer programmer and the owner of http://www.whichspamfilter.com, a web site which conducts weekly in-depth reviews of current spam filters, provides help and guidance in the fight against spam and provides a useful community forum. alan@whichspamfilter.com
RSS is the answer to the Spam epidemic of the... Read More
Microsoft scores one for the good guysScott Richter, the self-proclaimed... Read More
We receive so much information on the Internet, especially via... Read More
For years I didn't worry much about spam.But lately it's... Read More
Spam filter is the solution that most people resort when... Read More
Unless the filters on your computer are really good, you're... Read More
A friend of mine received a chilling email message from... Read More
Phishing is rapidly becoming on the largest threats to your... Read More
Email is rapidly becoming the standard means of communication among... Read More
With the number of spam filtering solutions increasing each week... Read More
Block Spam and Other Email Threats From Entering Your Gateway... Read More
E-mails now have a connection back to their servers. I... Read More
Spammers get email addresses from web pages using programs called... Read More
With SPAM being such a problem it might seem the... Read More
We've all become familiar with the term spam. It's become... Read More
You may have already received a do not spam list... Read More
Why do so many people think I need to take... Read More
Are you getting too much spam? We all are, but... Read More
My friends in the web hosting business have recently informed... Read More
Even being as careful as possible with my email address,... Read More
This review is taken DIRECTLY from a piece of "junk... Read More
Effectively stopping spam over the long-term requires much more than... Read More
How would you feel if you found a link on... Read More
The first thing I do every morning when I wake... Read More
English, German, Italian - It's All SPAM To MeHas anyone... Read More
No. I'm not talking here about the outdoor activity enjoyed... Read More
What do they do? How do they work? Which one... Read More
I imagine you have seen, heard about, or already know... Read More
Email is the quintessential business communication tool, so when it... Read More
Like everybody who will ever read this, I get spam... Read More
Each day we all face the same challenge. Spam. It... Read More
Q: I am so sick of all the spam that... Read More
The temptation among internet marketers to SPAM is greater than... Read More
It's no secret that the US economy has slowed down,... Read More
If you are buried in SPAM then you're not alone.... Read More
As the flood of spam increases end users are looking... Read More
Spam can be a lot more damaging than you might... Read More
You all tear your hair out in frustration every time... Read More
Anyone who uses email knows what Spam is!It's annoying and... Read More
No. I'm not talking here about the outdoor activity enjoyed... Read More
Q: I am so sick of all the spam that... Read More
Until recently, spam has been an annoyance, a definite load... Read More
You may have already received a do not spam list... Read More
6 August, 2004: Polesoft Inc., home of Professional anti spam... Read More
News last week that Internet service provider Verizon settled its... Read More
Effectively stopping spam over the long-term requires much more than... Read More
My friends in the web hosting business have recently informed... Read More
Over the past few years you've all become familiar with... Read More
When you receive an email telling you about a virus,... Read More
The first thing I do every morning when I wake... Read More
RSS is the answer to the Spam epidemic of the... Read More
Even being as careful as possible with my email address,... Read More
Junk mail works. Why does it work? How does it... Read More
Spam is out of control! I guess that would be... Read More
While we all admit that unsolicited commercial email is a... Read More
Spam can bring down your website faster than a speeding... Read More
Effectively stopping spam over the long-term requires much more than... Read More
Each day we all face the same challenge. Spam. It... Read More
One of our Australian clients sent out a campaign using... Read More
The harmful affects of pornography use and addiction are well... Read More
Spam filter is the solution that most people resort when... Read More
They're sneaky. And stealthy. They're quiet and mostly unobtrusive, but... Read More
No doubt about it."Spam" (unsolicited commercial email) threatens to paralyze... Read More
We all hate spam and get way too much of... Read More
A hearty welcome to all the spam fighting filters and... Read More
It absolutely amazes me how many people over-react to receiving... Read More
Spam Blocking |