Game Theory - What Do Game Theory and Improv Theater Have in Common?

"Game" Theory

This article was inspired by Mick Napier's book ?Improvise: scene from the inside out" in which he draws comparisons between Physics and Improvisation. It made me think ? I know a little bit about game theory (I majored in it) and it has the word "game" in it, so chances are it'll have something in common with improvising, which is really nothing else but playing games. And, not so surprisingly, there are some rather powerful parallels:

? To make everybody look good, you have to have cooperation. You have probably heard of the prisoner's dilemma. It is about two suspects, who are separated and each asked to confess. If one confesses and the other denies, the first gets off easy, the other gets 10 years. Being a snitch pays off. If both confess they each get 5 years. If both deny just 1. So, obviously the best solution is for both to deny. But if this expected, they will deviate and confess. Actually, it is always better to confess! So if there are no other means of cooperation then both will confess and get 5 years, which is far from the best outcome where both get 1 year. This debunks effectively the notion that individual selfishness maximizes common welfare!

The challenge here compares well with "going for the funny" (i.e. selfish behavior) in an improvised scene. If you do you'll get a laugh, sure. But if you both start going for the jokes you will look very silly. So, resist that urge and always play from the top of your intelligence. It's worth the effort.

? One of the most important things in improvisation is to be completely aware of everything going on in the scene. To be affected by it and not "script ahead" in your mind just to end up saying that stupid disconnected line that you thought would be so funny. In Game Theory too, this is an important rule. A strategy must be a best answer to the other players move. You must consider explicitly the reaction of the other players when you make your decision. Take the "winners curse" for example. You want to acquire a company that is worth somewhere between 0 and 100 dollars. Once you acquire the company it will be worth 1.5x that amount because of your better management. But here's the catch: only the seller knows what the actual worth is. So, what do you offer him? Take a second to think about your answer. Did you say 50 dollars? Because that is the expected value of the firm? You're in good company. But you were wrong. The correct answer is 0. Why 0? Well, let's say you offered $50 and the other party accepts. They will have only accepted your offer if the actual value is between 0 and 50 dollars, right? That means an expected value of $25. For you that is worth 1.5 times as much, or $37.5. The deal doesn't sound so good anymore? The same applies for every other amount offered. What you had to do to find this solution was simple enough: Put yourself in the other guy's shoes and think about your best answer to what she might do. Sound familiar?

? According to subgame perfectness you are not allowed to make unbelievable threats like "If you enter my market I will fight even though it costs me a lot of money", if this is not in your best interest once the event occurs. The way around this issue is to invest in "sunk cost". E.g. financial constructs, advertising, or your reputation that make it clear it will cost you dearly if you do not live up to your word. I.e. make it so expensive to bail that the threat once again becomes credible. In improvisation too you cannot bail on your offers. If you stuttered at the top of the scene, keep on stuttering. It's your contract with the audience. Yet, it is sometimes tempting to do so. Or, often you let go of it out of plain carelessness. So, invest highly at the top of the scene so it becomes impossible to go back.

? Trembling hand perfectness ? Means you must have an answer even to the most irrational moves. What if you find yourself in a world that cannot exist (an "unreached information set")? E.g. your competitor makes an incredibly stupid mistake. And sells PCs direct to consumer, no intermediaries. Although you know so well how important service is to your customers. What if this happens? How do you react? Basically, game theory says you have to have an answer for these situations too. The parallel to Improv? It's almost too obvious isn't it: you always have to have an answer. Nothing should throw you off balance. There's a horse in your kitchen? Right where you're baking that cake? Fine, work with that. Pet the horse, ride it over to the sink, milk it. Do whatever comes naturally to your character. React sincerely to it and you will be rewarded with interesting scenes. This one touches the very heart of improvisation as well as so many other business or private challenges: Take everything as a gift and be enough of a person to accept it. Then add to it. Yes And!

About the Author:

Henrik Kiessler is currently global Manager for CRM at a large Pharmaceutical firm. He lives in Vienna, Austria. He studied Game Theory with the acclaimed Werner Gueth in Frankfurt. He studied improvisation in Chicago with Second City and the Annoyance theater. The currently performs with ImproX (http://improx.fesch.at) in Vienna.

---

The Beothuk

Canada is an emancipated country in the relative scheme of... Read More

The Masked Fool

The FoolMy first direct experience of the fool in masking... Read More

Bureaucracy in Peru!

This article is from the pen of a New Zealander... Read More

Inuit Eskimo Art As Investments

Many people collect Inuit art as investments. Inuit art is... Read More

Sir Francis Drake

FRANCIS DRAKE: - It is my perspective that history has... Read More

Progress Versus Perfection

From the creative explosion marking the outset of the universe... Read More

Basic Chinese Pinyin Rules

* Make sure you set your browser encoding correctly to... Read More

The American Melting Pot Myth

Most myths have some element of truth in them. The... Read More

Learn How To Draw Faces Realistically

Drawing a face isn't as hard as it looks. To... Read More

An Interview on History and Educational Media

1. Can you briefly summarize why you think history is... Read More

Hello I Must Be Going: The Vanishing Twin

They walk among us. By the mid nineties, science had... Read More

Sixties: The Decade of Rebellion

It is safe to say that in the... Read More

The Red Violin - Film Review

The film portrays the creation, fate, and redemption of a... Read More

African Americans: Get the Winning Edge

Everybody wants an edge that will give him or her... Read More

When We Was Kids In Chicago

Radio was the big communicator, back when I was a... Read More

The History of Body Piercings - Ancient and Fascinating Around the World

Body piercings have seen a resurgence of interest in the... Read More

Egyptian Handmade Perfume Bottles

Blown glass, a very ancient technique, is the oldest among... Read More

Europes New Jews

They inhabit self-imposed ghettoes, subject to derision and worse, the... Read More

The Sterling Silver Story

Silver is the most common of the Precious Metals. It's... Read More

Export/Import of Inuit Eskimo Art Sculpture Containing Whalebone or Ivory

The export of certain Inuit sculpture from Canada to other... Read More

Archaeology and Spirit Guides

One of the northern derivatives of Hopewell of interest to... Read More

Flows of Civilization; Views from a Think Tank

Over the past few years we have been discussing many... Read More

Ernesto Apomayta offers Explanation of Mediums, Paints, & Techniques Used by Artists

Special Types of MediumsRice paper is a very delicate medium... Read More

Rasputin

GRIGORY EFIMOVICH NOVYKH (RASPUTIN):'Hail, Hail, Ras-putin'. This man's story has... Read More

OM to Ogham

Plato observed that the advent of an alphabet making writing... Read More

Feng Shui North versus South Hemisphere

The North South Hemisphere Question:The question of whether or not... Read More

Violence

Flashes of memory stream into my consciousness. They take me... Read More

Her Last Day in Court

"Ron, I can't take much more of his sleazy behavior!... Read More

Better Red than Dead!

Red, perhaps the first color our eyes perceive.It is said... Read More

Berenguer Sauniere - This Place is Terrible

INSPIRATIONAL COMMENTS:"Let me issue and control a nation's money and... Read More

Arthur Koestler

ARTHUR KOESTLER:Humanitarian, historian and scientist are just a few of... Read More

Moissanite Earrings, The Modern Brazilian Beetle

The history of earrings is a varied history indeed. And... Read More

Body Jewelry and Todays Stars

Body jewelry and body piercing practices have been observed by... Read More