Rolling your 401k: Contributory IRA vs. Rollover IRA

In an ideal world you would start your working career with a great company in your early 20s, steadily climb the corporate ladder, retire at age 65, and draw a sufficient income from your accumulated 401k account to live happily ever after.

Unfortunately, that's not how the real world works. If you are like most people, you will change careers, or at least companies, several times. Each time, you'll be faced with the question of what to do with your accumulated 401k benefits.

You will likely have a few choices: keep your 401k with your old employer (sometimes possible), roll the proceeds into your new employer's 401k plan, or put them directly into a self-directed IRA at a brokerage firm of your choice.

Since leaving your 401k with your ex-employer has no benefits whatsoever and most employers will prefer you transfer out anyway, that leaves only the last two as viable options:

1. Roll your 401k proceeds into the new employer's 401k plan of (if allowed)

This is the most painless solution and the one that does not require much decision making. While this is certainly acceptable, there is a bigger picture.

The ultimate goal of having a 401k plan is to provide you with a comfortable retirement. To accomplish this you really need a wide variety of investment choices and the opportunity to move among them in response to market variations.

Most 401ks are limited to maybe 15 mutual fund choices which rarely change, even if market behavior dictates they should. Additionally, the canned advice provided through plan sponsors is generally not terribly useful.

The only benefit to this type of rollover is that if your plan has a loan provision, you'll be able to borrow funds easily.

2. Roll your 401k proceeds into a self directed IRA

This is the preferable solution for most people, and with it you again have two choices: roll your 401k into a "Contributory" or a "Rollover" IRA.

Contributory IRA:

Once you roll your proceeds into this type of IRA, you may still contribute annually if you qualify (check with your accountant). However, the 401k portion can no longer be rolled back into another 401k with a new employer, should you ever want to do that. So you eliminate the possibility of using the loan provision with those funds. While it is possible to borrow against an IRA, it's more limited than borrowing against an employer 401k. Check with your tax preparer for details.

Rollover IRA:

This type of IRA allows you the most flexibility. You may roll the proceeds back into a 401k plan if you want to utilize a loan provision. However, for tax reasons you should not make annual contributions to this IRA. If making annual contributions becomes important to you, simply open another contributory IRA.

Since Rollover IRAs are usually set up at a brokerage firm, you'll have access to their entire universe of mutual funds. With this type of IRA, you can also employ an independent investment advisor to manage the account for you. (Yes there is a cost for that, but an effective advisor will more than make up for that in greater returns than you would get without him or her.)

Most of my clients have found that the investment results we've obtained with their personal IRAs were far superior to those yielded by their employer 401k plans or their personal investing efforts. This has been mainly due to a combination of better choices and a methodical approach to investing which has kept my clients in the market during good times and out of it altogether during severe declines.

Bottom line: Rollover IRAs offer opportunities to maximize benefits and provide flexibility not usually available with employer 401k plans.

About The Author

Ulli Niemann is an investment advisor and has been writing about objective, methodical approaches to investing for over 10 years. He eluded the bear market of 2000 and has helped countless people make better investment decisions. To find out more about his approach and his FREE Newsletter, please visit: www.successful-investment.com; ulli@successful-investment.com

In The News:


pen paper and inkwell


cat break through


Investing In or Owning Drug Lab Properties

Clean Up (includes the insides and the outside of a... Read More

DXPortfolio: A Great Passive Investment of 25% to $40% per month

First, I need to explain about e-currencies or digital currencies.... Read More

Building The Foundation For Wealth

You wouldn't build your home on anything less than a... Read More

Do You Need A Financial Planner?

No matter how much money you make, it pays to... Read More

Now is the Time to Invest for Your Retirement!

Yes, it's the time we've all been waiting for?tax season!... Read More

Investing & Online Stock & Share Trading: Money & Risk Management - Atkinson Portfolio Planner (1)

This article was originally featured in Daryl Guppy's 'Tutorials in... Read More

Day Traders and Swing Traders and Options? Maybe!

Typical day traders and swing traders look for stocks with... Read More

Day Trading the SP Futures with Initial S/R and the NYSE TICK

For instance, if the market moves up in the first... Read More

Out-Of-State Investors Check List of Questions

The following lists of questions are suggested questions to ask... Read More

The American Age of Inflation is Over

"The American Age of Inflation is finished." So says economist... Read More

Investing in Car Dealerships: Doing Your Homework

This article attempts to help give the investor a broader... Read More

California Deparment of Corporations and Franchise Opportunities Law

What CA Needs To Do To Address Issues in FranchisingWe... Read More

Advice for International Investors on How to Safeguard Their Profits

What are the risks?Today, investors are increasingly turning to global... Read More

Critical Investors Business Daily Responsibilities - If not Followed Could Cost You Millions!

When thinking about the investors business daily responsibilities in today’s... Read More

Protecting the Tax Advantage of Your Deferred Compensation

The American Jobs Creation Act of 2004 imposed strict new... Read More

Begging Your Trust in Africa

The syntax is tortured, the grammar mutilated, but the message... Read More

The Demise of Buy & Hold

Based on consistent results I think Buy & Hold should... Read More

Franchise Opportunity Sellers Beware; franchise buyers lie on forms?

It seems completely absurd that franchise buyers lie about their... Read More

The Perfect Economy?

The U.S. economic data reported this week showed strong output... Read More

Volatile Oil

The Light Crude Continuous Contract fell from $67.70 a barrel... Read More

Buy: Hold: Sell: Jump

I'm sitting here at my computer desk with a cup... Read More

The Power of Small Numbers: Trading Success is Based on Consistency, Not Home Runs

Online trading is so seductive - just sit, click, and... Read More

Time is Money and We Are Running Out of Both!

One of the fundamental principles of finance is the concept... Read More

Investing As A Sport?

I said last week that money doesn't generally buy happiness,... Read More

Scots Beat Yanks in China Bank Deal

With visions of an ATM in every neighborhood in China,... Read More

How to Invest Your Money

Think carefully on how to invest your money because if... Read More

Value Investing

By definition, value investing is the process of selecting stocks... Read More

25 Ways to Find Companies to Buy

When you start your program to purchase your "ideal" company,... Read More

The Economys Greatest Depression Downturn Ever Is Now Just A Few Years Away

What really controls the economy? Forget interest rates, forget deficits,... Read More

Selecting Rules for Investing and Trading

There are three important differences between investing and trading. Overlooking... Read More

How Do I Start Investing Online and What Are Some Basic Tips?

If you are new to investing online, don't put your... Read More

Stocks: Reduce Risk Yet Maximize Profits

It is important to note that every smart investor wants... Read More

Preparing to Invest: How to get started

Investments can be a source of great potential earnings. The... Read More